Photo: Fred Jagueneau/Bravo (2)

BELOW DECK SAILING YACHT – Season:4 – Pictured: Daisy Kelliher – (Photo by: Fred Jagueneau/Bravo); BELOW DECK SAILING YACHT – Season:4 – Pictured: Colin Macrae – (Photo by: Fred Jagueneau/Bravo)

Below Deck Sailing Yachtfans have been surprised to seeDaisy KelliherandColin MacRaetake their relationship to a new levelin season 4, but the Chief Stewardess reveals the escalation wasn’t much of a blindside for her.

“I think I knew before we were [interested in each other] coming into this season,” Kelliher exclusively tells PEOPLE about her chemistry with the Chief Engineer, who was single for his first charter since the pair began their three-year friendship on and off the show.

When the night finally came whenthe pair kissed and cuddled, Kelliher recalls, “I think Colin kind of made more of the first move. He knew I was going to be receptive.”

She continues, “So I am going to say the ball was in his court, but we both knew it was going to happen. I think the two of us kind of leaned into it.”

Bravo

Below Deck Sailing Yacht Season 4

In fact, the yachtie reveals the sparks with MacRae might have ignited sooner if not for a silly smooch in the hot tub with deckhand Alex Propson early in the season.

Laurent Basset/Bravo (2)

BELOW DECK SAILING YACHT – Season:3 – Pictured: Gary King – (Photo by: Laurent Basset/Bravo); BELOW DECK SAILING YACHT – Season:3 – Pictured: Daisy Kelliher – (Photo by: Laurent Basset/Bravo)

Making things more complicated, Kelliher and King — who kissed once last season after a drunken night out — also came into the season with different ideas about whether their friendship could turn into more.

Despite King’s hopes, Kelliher knew where her heart was — with MacRae.

“I didn’t regret my kiss with Gary, but there was no point to it. It wasn’t going to go anywhere. He wasn’t proving to me that he wanted something else,” she explains. “So with Colin it was different. When I did, I was like,I don’t know, maybe there is something there. Maybe there is a future there.”

She continues, “I was like, ‘Maybe Colin and I might have something there? We’ve been through so much. We care so much about each other, and we have a strong bond doing the show, we enjoy each other’s company.’ So that was my primary focus.”

Below Deck Sailing Yacht Season 4

But the friends–turned–kissers' future is set to be in double jeopardy during Monday night’sBelow Deck, a back-to-back airing that will find a"jealous"King rashly revealing that his and Kelliher’s past is actuallymuch more intimate than a kiss.

With growing pressure on both of her relationships, Kelliher understands thatBelow Deckfans might be inclined to root for one man or the other.

On the one hand, she says, “Colin has been seen as this perfect gentleman,” and on the other hand, King — who’s been hooking up with stewardess Madison “Mads” Herrera since early into the charter season — might make fans “think, ‘Well, Gary’s not exactly proving himself to be marriage material.’ So they just want the best for me. And I think the natural progression or the natural kind of leniency towards Colin is there.”

Regardless of where viewers' allegiances lie, Kelliher can say one thing for certain: “We could all go on and have partners and be well-behaved and look perfect. But going on single and playing that role is a whole ‘nother ball game.”

Never miss a story — sign up forPEOPLE’s free daily newsletterto stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

Below Deck Sailing Yachtairs Mondays at 8 p.m. ET on Bravo.

source: people.com