Heather Morris and Lea Michele during the ‘Blame It on the Alcohol’ episode of ‘Glee’.Photo:FOX Image Collection via Getty

The glee club performs in the “Blame It on the Alcohol” episode

FOX Image Collection via Getty

On Sunday’s episode of theAnd That’s What You REALLY Missedpodcast, hostsKevin McHaleandJenna Ushkowitzrecounted how the season 2 episode titled “Blame It on the Alcohol” came to be based on real events.

“We went out, and I won’t name names. There was one person who was the ringleader. It wasn’t either of us … [they] started pushing us all to drink,” McHale revealed. “And we’re like ‘I don’t know if we should.’ Some of us partook more than others.”

“Then the producers came down and they partook in our dance party … but then went back and snitched on us and we got in trouble,” recalled Ushkowitz. “And they wrote an episode about it.”

Jesse Grant/Getty

Jenna Ushkowitz and Kevin McHale attend iHeartRadio 102.7 KIIS FM’s Jingle Ball 2022 Presented by Capital One at The Kia Forum on December 02, 2022 in Inglewood, California

In the episode, the New Directions glee club was tasked with performing at the school assembly to promote Alcohol Awareness Week. Ironically,Lea Michele’s character Rachel decided to throw a house party where the entire group had too much to drink. Later on, the drunken antics ended with them throwing up onstage from being too intoxicated.

Along with the the cast’s off-camera game of Spin the Bottle, the writers incorporated several of the stars’ real-life mannerisms in their onscreen counterparts.

“There were a lot of our ‘isms’ in this entire thing. Where Santana mouths ‘Kiss me’ … She’s sort of making fun of herself,” he said ofNaya Rivera’s ad-lib. “We’re making fun of each other in all of this.”

Heather Morris and Jenna Ushkowitz during the ‘Blame It on the Alcohol’ episode of ‘Glee’.FOX Image Collection via Getty

The glee club performs in the “Blame It on the Alcohol” episode

Ushkowitz added that just like Rivera, Santana also said “No me gusta” in the episode. McHale remembered that Michele, 36, would always yell “Cheers,” both as herself and as Rachel.

Ushkowitz’s own “cackle” became a part of her character Tina Cohen-Chang’s drunken behavior, along with McHale’s habit of trying on women’s clothes.

“We could just do what we wanted,” noted McHale, who played Artie Abrams. “It was very much just like what Kevin did. I definitely put on some of the girls’ clothing and just [went] for it.”

‘Glee’ cast in season 2.Patrick Ecclesine/Fox Television/Everett

GLEE

Patrick Ecclesine/Fox Television/Everett

Of filming the the party scene, McHale said: “It was so funny, and we were all losing our minds off camera the whole time… We did the party over and over and over again.”

Added Ushkowitz, “It felt like a party. It really did.”

Never miss a story — sign up forPEOPLE’s free daily newsletterto stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

iHeartRadio drops new episodes ofAnd That’s What You REALLY Missedweekly across multiple podcast platforms.

source: people.com